Shiloh Shepherd VS German Shepherd: What’s The Difference?

Share This

When it comes to dogs as pets, the Shiloh Shepherd and the German Shepherd are two breeds that get a lot of attention and praise. 

If you want to know what makes a Shiloh Shepherd different from a German Shepherd, you’ve come to the right place. In this thorough guide, we’ll go on an enlightening trip to find out what makes these two breeds different and what makes them special.

Shiloh Shepherds and German Shepherds are both different in size, personality and how much exercise they need. Their health and grooming procedures also differ to a good extent. By the end of this article, you’ll not only be able to tell them apart, but you’ll also be able to choose which breed might be the best fit for your family.

Now, let’s embark on a captivating exploration of the lovely domains of Shiloh Shepherds and German Shepherds, as we explore their unique differences. Discovering your perfect canine companion is a delightful journey that awaits you.

Do you know what is the difference between a Shiloh Shepherd and a German Shepherd?

Before getting into the details, let’s answer the most important question: what makes a Shiloh Shepherd different from a German Shepherd? Known for being smart, loyal, and versatile. But both breeds are different in size, look, demeanor, exercise needs, grooming needs, health factors, and even price. 

Shiloh shepherd origin and history:

The Shiloh Shepherd is a relatively new breed of dog with an interesting story about how it came to be. Bred in the United States at the end of the 20th century. The goal was to keep the best parts of the classic German Shepherd while solving some worries about the breed’s health and behavior.


The Shiloh Shepherd, which is often called the “gentle giant,” is a newer breed than the German Shepherd. Originating in the United States in the 1970s, bred with a focus on keeping the German Shepherd’s positive traits while lowering some of the health issues associated with the breed.

The Visionary Behind the Breed

Tina Barber’s hard work and ideas led to the creation of the Shiloh Shepherd breed. Tina Barber was very keen on German Shepherds around the 1960s and 1970s. She started to worry about where the breed was going. She thought that the breed was losing some of its most important traits, like its strong health and calm personality.

Tina Barber wanted to keep the original qualities of the breed, so she set out to make a new type of Shepherd that had all the qualities she loved.

The Name “Shiloh Shepherd”

The breed derived its name from its foundation dog, Shiloh, and this name was officially adopted for the new breed. Thus, the Shiloh Shepherd was born.


The International Shiloh Shepherd Dog Club (ISSDC), which Tina Barber helped to start, recognized the Shiloh Shepherd as a separate breed in 1991. The ISSDC was the official register for the breed and the group in charge of managing it overall. Several other dog groups also paid attention to the Shiloh Shepherd.

Unique Traits of the Shiloh Shepherd

This program of meticulous breeding led to the Shiloh Shepherd, known for its size, kindness, loyalty, and adaptability. It has the best parts of the original German Shepherd and the changes Tina Barber wanted to make to the dog’s health and behavior.

The past of the Shiloh Shepherd is short but has a point. It was created to keep the best parts of the German Shepherd while also fixing some problems. Today, the breed is a tribute to Tina Barber’s hard work and the work of others who shared her goal of a healthy, more balanced Shepherd breed.

German Shepherd‘s Origin and History

German Shepherds are one of the most popular and recognizable dog breeds globally, known for their exceptional intelligence and versatility. These dogs originated in Germany in the late 19th century and were initially bred for herding and guarding livestock. Over the years, their roles have expanded to include police work, search and rescue, and as loyal family pets.

Origin of German Shepherd

This breed’s development is closely tied to the efforts of dedicated individuals who sought to create a versatile and intelligent working dog.

The Early Roots

The German Shepherd comes from the late 19th century and the early 20th century in Germany. During this time, the rural areas of Germany needed a flexible herding dog that could work with sheep and other animals.

Local herding dogs were very different in how they looked and what they could do, so people tried to make the breed more uniform and better.

Captain Max von Stephanitz

Captain Max von Stephanitz is responsible for making the German Shepherd the breed it is today. Von Stephanitz went to a dog show in 1899, where he met a dog called Hektor Linksrhein. He was very impressed by Hektor’s knowledge, power, and general way of being. Von Stephanitz got the idea to make a regular breed of herding dog during this meeting.

Discovery of the Breed

In 1899, Von Stephanitz and other people who agreed with him set up the Society for the German Shepherd Dog (SV, or Verein für Deutsche Schaferhunde). This was when the breed got its legal start. Hektor Linksrhein was renamed Horand von Grafrath and became the very first known German Shepherd. Considered to be the father of the breed!

The Standard

A breed standard made with von Stephanitz’s help. This standard listed the physical and behavioral traits that German Shepherds should have. The goal was to make a breed that was not only good at hunting but also good at other types of work.

The Modern German Shepherd

Today, the German Shepherd is famous as a classic and adaptable breed. Known for their hard work ethic, cleverness, and loyalty. They are great at many different jobs, from police and military work to search and rescue tasks. Their success as family pets is also well-earned, as they are loving and protective friends.

In the end, the German Shepherd’s history is a testament to the vision and hard work of people like Captain Max von Stephanitz, who wanted to make a breed that was smart, strong, and flexible. This breed has come a long way from being simple herding dogs to being well-known working dogs and family pets. This is a sign of their lasting popularity and value.

CharacteristicShiloh ShepherdsGerman Shepherds
Height26 to 30 inches at the shoulderMales: 24 to 26 inches, Females: 22 to 24 inches
Weight80 to 140 poundsMales: 65 to 90 pounds, Females: 50 to 70 pounds
Coat TypesDense, double coat, plush, straight, medium to longDouble coat with dense, straight, or slightly wavy topcoat, soft undercoat
ColorsVarious, including sable, black and tan, solid blackMost common: black and tan; other variations include solid black, sable, all-black, and more

Shiloh Shepherd Vs German Shepherd: Appearance

While both Shiloh Shepherds and German Shepherds share the same canine ancestry, their appearances have evolved differently over the years.

Shiloh shepherd’s Appearance

Shiloh Shepherds are famous for looking powerful and majestic. Their big size, strong build, and soft fur give them an air of royalty. With almond-shaped eyes and a head that is the right size, they look gentle but alert. 

The backs of these dogs are usually straight, and when they rest, their tails hang down. The different colors of their coats add to their unique charm and help them stand out in a crowd.

German Shepherd’s Appearance

People love German Shepherds because of how easily recognizable and iconic they look. They are powerful, well-balanced dogs with strong, noble heads. Their eyes are a good size, brown, and active, which shows how smart and alert they are. 

One thing that makes a German Shepherd a German Shepherd is that its back is sloped. Their tail is long and goes all the way to their hips. Their black and tan saddle design makes them stand out and makes it easy to spot them.

Shiloh Shepherd Vs German Shepherd: Temperament

Temperament plays a crucial role in choosing the right dog breed for your family. Let’s explore how Shiloh Shepherds and German Shepherds compare in this aspect.

Shiloh Shepherd’s Temperament

Shiloh Shepherds are very pleasant and compassionate. They are extremely helpful and affectionate with their families, which makes them great pets for families. These dogs are faithful and loyal to their owners, and they form strong bonds with them. 

Their natural desire to protect makes them great watchdogs, as they will let their owners know if they see something that could be dangerous. Shiloh Shepherds usually like kids and can be very patient with them. But they need to get used to people and other animals from a young age to be comfortable around both.

German Shepherd’s Temperament

Known for their intelligence, German Shepherds are exceptionally loyal. They can do numerous tasks. People often say they are bold and brave, which makes them great working dogs. These dogs are famous for being protective, which is why they are often used in police and military jobs. 

German Shepherds are also great family dogs. They make strong bonds with their owners and are great with kids. But they need early training so they don’t become overprotective or afraid of strangers.

Shiloh Shepherd Vs German Shepherd: Exercise

Both Shiloh Shepherds and German Shepherds are active breeds that require regular exercise to stay happy and healthy. However, their exercise needs may differ.

Shiloh Shepherd’s Exercise Needs

Shiloh Shepherds don’t need a lot of motion for their size. To keep them physically and mentally active, they need to go for daily walks, play, and have access to a fenced yard where they can run and explore. 

They like to be outside, so hikes and playing “fetch” are great ways to keep them busy. Because they are so protective, they may also benefit from agility training to help them use their energy in a good way.

German Shepherd’s Exercise Needs

German Shepherds have endless energy. They like to be physically and mentally challenged and do well in agility and obedience training. Every day exercise is a must to keep them happy and prevent behavior problems. 

Expect to do things like long walks, jogs, and fun in a big yard. They also like jobs that test their intelligence, which makes them good candidates for canine sports and obedience training.

Shiloh Shepherd Vs German Shepherd: Shedding

Both breeds have double coats, which means they will shed, but the extent of shedding varies.

Shiloh Shepherd’s Shedding

Shiloh Shepherds have average shedding. Their soft double coat sheds all year long, but it sheds more in the spring and fall. Regular brushing can help control shedding and keep their hair in good condition. If you or someone in your family has allergies, this is a crucial thing to think about.

German Shepherd’s Shedding

People know that German Shepherds shed a lot. They shed all year, but they shed more when the seasons change. To keep the hair under control, this breed needs to be brushed and groomed often. If you get a German Shepherd, you should expect to find dog hair on your clothes, furniture, and floors.

Shiloh Shepherd Vs German Shepherd: Grooming

Grooming needs also play a role in the day-to-day care of these breeds.

Shiloh Shepherd’s Grooming Needs

Shiloh Shepherds don’t need much care when it comes to grooming. At least once a week, you should brush their medium-to-long hair to keep it from getting tangled and to cut down on shedding. They also need to clean their ears, brush their teeth, and trim their nails every day. Bathing should take place if needed, usually every couple of months or when they get dirty.

German Shepherd’s Grooming Needs

Because they shed a lot, German Shepherds need more cleaning than other dogs. The coat needs to be brushed at least a few times a week to stay healthy and to cut down on hair all over your house. 

They also need their ears cleaned, their teeth brushed, and their nails trimmed regularly. Baths should be given when they need them, which is usually every couple of months or when they get into something messy.

Health Factors

Ensuring the health and well-being of your future canine companion is a top priority. Let’s examine the health factors associated with Shiloh Shepherds and German Shepherds.

Shiloh Shepherd’s Health

Shiloh Shepherds are generally considered a healthy breed with a life expectancy of around 10 to 14 years. Regular vet check-ups are essential to monitor their health and address any potential issues promptly. They may be prone to certain health concerns, including hip dysplasia and bloat, which are common in large breeds.

  • Hip dysplasia: A hereditary disorder that causes arthritis and mobility difficulties in the hip joint. Regular veterinary checkups and a healthy weight can lower Shiloh Shepherd’s hip dysplasia risk.

Like hip dysplasia, elbow dysplasia is a developmental disorder that affects the elbow joint. It causes pain and lameness in dogs. This risk can be reduced by responsible breeding.

  • Bloat: A life-threatening illness in which a dog’s stomach fills with gas and twists, called bloat. Not handled quickly, it can kill. Shiloh Feeding deep-chested shepherds smaller, more frequent meals and avoiding intense movement after eating may lessen bloat risk.
  • Degenerative Myelopathy: A degenerative spinal cord illness that can cause hind limb weakness and paralysis. It’s more frequent in German Shepherds but can harm Shiloh Shepherds. No cure, although physical therapy and support can improve a dog’s life.
  • Panosteitis:  “growing pains,” can plague young Shiloh Shepherds. It causes lameness and pain in the long leg bones but usually goes away with age.

German Shepherd’s Health

German Shepherds can also live healthy lives, with a typical lifespan of around 9 to 13 years. However, they are prone to specific health issues, including hip and elbow dysplasia, bloat, and degenerative myelopathy. Responsible breeding practices and regular vet visits can help mitigate these risks.

  • Elbow dysplasia: Like hip dysplasia, elbow dysplasia is a developing elbow problem. It causes pain and lameness. Responsible breeding and nutrition reduce risk. This life-threatening illness causes the stomach to fill with gas and twist. Deep-chested German Shepherds may bloat. 

Reduce risk by feeding them smaller, more frequent meals and avoiding strenuous exercise after eating.

  • Degenerative Myelopathy: Older German Shepherds have this spinal cord disorder. Hind limb weakness and paralysis can result. Despite no cure, physical therapy and support can improve a dog’s life.

German Shepherds can develop exocrine pancreatic insufficiency (EPI), a pancreatic disorder that lacks digesting enzymes. Weight loss, diarrhea, and starvation might result. Enzyme supplements and a particular diet help.

  • Skin issues: German Shepherds can get allergies and hot spots. Managing skin disorders requires allergy identification and veterinary consultation.
  • Eye Conditions: German Shepherds can get PRA and cataracts. Eye exams can detect and treat these disorders. Panosteitis, sometimes known as “growing pains,” can cause lameness and discomfort in young German Shepherds. Age usually cures it.

German Shepherds can get dilated cardiomyopathy. Veterinary checkups can spot heart abnormalities early.

Life Expectancy

The life expectancy of a dog is an important consideration when choosing a breed.

Shiloh Shepherd’s Life Expectancy

Shiloh Shepherds generally have a longer life expectancy compared to German Shepherds. On average, they can live between 10 to 14 years, provided they receive proper care and attention.

German Shepherd’s Life Expectancy

German Shepherds have a slightly shorter life expectancy, typically ranging from 9 to 13 years. While this may vary based on individual health and genetics, it’s essential to be prepared for the responsibilities that come with caring for an aging dog.

Shiloh Shepherd Vs German Shepherd: Price 2023

When it comes to purchasing a puppy, the cost can vary significantly between these two breeds.

  • Shiloh Shepherd Price 2023

In 2023, the price of a Shiloh Shepherd puppy can range from $1,500 to $3,000 or more. Factors such as pedigree, breeder reputation, and location can influence the price.

  • German Shepherd Price 2023

German Shepherd puppies can also vary in price. In 2023, you can expect to pay between $800 and $2,500 or more for a German Shepherd puppy. As with Shiloh Shepherds, factors like breeder reputation and lineage can affect the price.

BreedShiloh ShepherdGerman Shepherd
Price 2023$1,500 to $3,000 or more$800 to $2,500 or more
Factors Affecting PricePedigree, breeder reputation, locationPedigree, breeder reputation, location

In Conclusion

Choosing between a Shiloh Shepherd and a German Shepherd is a big choice that should fit with your lifestyle, preferences, and ability to meet their needs. Both breeds have unique traits and make great pets, but you should choose between them based on their size, grooming needs, exercise needs, and health. 

Whether you choose the gentle giant Shiloh Shepherd or the famously versatile German Shepherd, you’re sure to find a loyal and loving animal friend to add to your family.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *